Senate Majority Leader John Thune Floats a Diesel Export Ban as Prices Hit Record Highs. Trump Pivots to a Russia Deal Instead.

Published September 17, 2026, 9:36am ET · 6 min read

Market Pulse desk. Editor: AJ Tiarsmith, PhD.

This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.

© Chip Somodevilla / Getty Images News via Getty Images

US retail diesel prices hit an all-time high in September 2026, and Washington spent weeks openly debating a policy tool it has never before applied to a refined petroleum product: an export ban. The national average reached $6.53 per gallon on September 21-22, 2026, according to the US Energy Information Administration, surpassing a September monthly average of $6.29-6.33 per gallon that itself set a new record. Against that backdrop, Colorado Politics reported on September 15, 2026, that Senate Majority Leader John Thune said he was open to exploring a diesel export ban, telling reporters, “If the United States has the supply and is exporting it, that might be one way of getting at it.”

Squeeze From Three Directions

The price surge traces to three compounding supply shocks hitting the market simultaneously. Continued war-related disruption to Iranian and Middle East oil flows has tightened crude supplies for global refiners. Ukrainian drone strikes on Russian refineries, meanwhile, have taken meaningful volumes of Russian diesel production offline, in a country responsible for roughly one in nine barrels of global diesel output. Those two shocks effectively positioned the US as one of the few exporters with spare diesel-making capacity, and global buyers responded accordingly.

That demand pull had a visible effect on domestic inventories. US distillate exports set a new all-time record of 1.9 million barrels per day in the week ending July 31, 2026, capping five consecutive weeks above 1.5 million barrels per day. The sustained outflow drove domestic distillate stockpiles to their lowest seasonal level since 1996. US retail regular gasoline averaged $4.32 per gallon nationally for the week ending September 14, 2026, up $0.31 from a month earlier, as the broader energy complex tightened.

Burgum Pushes Back on the Mechanics

The Trump administration’s initial response was skeptical. Speaking at the G20 Energy Ministerial in Houston, Interior Secretary Doug Burgum said, “We would consider an export ban if we thought that actually might lower prices, but that’s not the case.” He warned that a ban could invite retaliation from trading partners and would hurt consumers in import-dependent states like California.

The technical objection runs deeper than politics. The Center for Strategic and International Studies estimates roughly 70% of US refining capacity is configured to process heavy, sour crude imported from abroad, not the light, sweet crude produced from American shale fields. A ban that trapped domestic light crude inside US borders would not automatically yield more diesel, because the refineries best positioned to produce it cannot easily process what would be available. CSIS concluded a ban would not deliver “sustained fuel price relief,” and warned that refiners squeezed below profitable operating margins could simply reduce output, deepening the very shortage policymakers hoped to solve.

Oil-state Republicans in the Senate reinforced that analysis. Senator John Cornyn of Texas dismissed the proposal as “a gimmick.” Senator Kevin Cramer of North Dakota was blunter: “If you restrict access to the global market for our diesel production, you literally disincentivize more diesel production, in which case you end up with higher prices, lower supply.” Senator Lisa Murkowski of Alaska questioned whether the ban was worth disrupting global markets for what she called a “short-term” benefit “that doesn’t really move the needle.”

Farm-State Republicans Push the Other Way

The political pressure on the other side was just as real. High diesel costs are a direct operating expense for farmers, truckers, and heating-oil customers, and Republicans representing those constituencies pushed hard for relief before November’s midterm elections. Senator Chuck Grassley of Iowa proposed a formal 90-day halt to diesel exports, and farm-state House Republicans including Representative Ashley Hinson of Iowa quickly signed on, calling the Iran conflict responsible for the price spike and demanding relief.

The division exposed a geographic fault line inside the Senate Republican conference. Senators from oil-refining states blocked the export ban as well as a proposal to loosen limits on E15 ethanol-blended gasoline, while budget hawks opposed a federal gas-tax suspension over its impact on the Highway Trust Fund. By early October the infighting had stalled every proposal, leaving no legislative relief in place before Election Day.

Trump Shifts Direction: The White House Moves, Then Pivots

The White House initially remained non-committal. Spokeswoman Taylor Rogers said, “President Trump remains committed to unleashing American energy dominance, cutting costs, and putting more money back in the pockets of hardworking American families. As the U.S. continues to maintain full control of the Strait of Hormuz, oil and gas prices will fall back to pre-conflict levels.” That statement marked a shift from an earlier position in which the Interior Department said the “Trump administration has no plan to implement restrictions on oil and gas exports.”

By September 22, Trump had moved further. When asked at a press briefing whether he supported a diesel export ban endorsed by Republican colleagues, Trump said he had called for one too. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, sitting beside him, said the administration was examining “whether it’s feasible in terms of the overall refining capacity, and whether a full or a partial ban would work.” Trump indicated a decision would come “fast, one way or the other.”

It came differently than expected. On October 9, 2026, Trump announced he had reached a deal with Russian President Vladimir Putin during a phone call to supply Russian diesel to US and global markets. Trump wrote on Truth Social that Russia would immediately supply more than 300,000 tons of diesel, followed by 500,000 tons in November and 1 million tons thereafter, with an additional 3 million tons promised “within a short period of time.” The same day, the Treasury Department issued a temporary general license suspending US sanctions on Russian diesel deliveries through April 2027, effectively reopening American ports to Russian fuel barred since 2022. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy condemned the deal as “a gift to Putin.” A growing number of Senate Republicans also rejected it, and senior Democrats moved to preserve financial records related to the deal for a potential post-election investigation.

Trump’s commentary before the Russia deal focused partly on US producers. On August 3, 2026, he posted on Truth Social that without his administration “the Oil Industry, and our Country itself, would be DEAD!” and accused ExxonMobil (NYSE:XOM | XOM Price Prediction) and Chevron (NYSE:CVX) of “making too much money.”

A Tool Washington Has Never Used

The United States banned crude oil exports beginning in 1975 and lifted that ban in 2015. Refined products like diesel and gasoline have never been subject to a comparable export ban in the modern era. By late October 2026, diesel prices had retreated from their September peak to approximately $6.28-6.34 per gallon, still roughly 71% above year-ago levels, and Washington’s attention had turned from restricting exports to managing the diplomatic and legal fallout from buying Russian supply instead.

Editor’s note: This article has been updated to reflect post-publication developments including the all-time diesel price record of $6.53 per gallon reached on September 21-22, 2026 (EIA), the record US distillate export figure of 1.9 million barrels per day (week ending July 31, EIA), the collapse of the Senate Republican export-ban coalition due to oil-state opposition, Trump’s endorsement and subsequent abandonment of the export ban in favor of a Russian diesel supply agreement announced October 9 with a Treasury sanction waiver through April 2027, and the ongoing Democratic investigation into that deal.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.

AJ Tiarsmith

AJ spent 10 years writing about financial markets at The Motley Fool. His coverage centers on technology stocks and the broader macroeconomic trends, from interest rates to geopolitics,  that shape where markets are headed next. AJ is drawn to the stories where big-picture economics and individual companies collide.

All articles →