Kalshi Says New York Could Shut It Down Nationwide
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
A company’s street address is now at the center of a fight over a national market. On Thursday, November 19, 2026, U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick sent New York Attorney General Letitia James’s enforcement suit against Kalshi back to state court. He ordered the transfer carried out immediately.
Late that night, Kalshi’s lawyers asked Justice Melissa Crane of the Manhattan Supreme Court for a status conference. They also asked for notice and a chance to file arguments before any renewed temporary restraining order, which is a short-term court order that stops activity until a hearing.
Kalshi warns that an order barring contracts offered “within or from New York” would reach customers in every state because the company is headquartered there. That matters to Robinhood (NASDAQ:HOOD | HOOD Price Prediction), which offers sports contracts through Kalshi.
Robinhood closed Friday at $62.17, down 9.44%, on a day the S&P 500 fell 3.70%. No source ties the drop to Kalshi. After hours, it traded at $64.05, up 3.02%, as of 6:31 p.m. ET.
A Ruling on Venue That Leaves the Core Question Open
Broderick decided only which court hears the case. He found the lone federal question, a Wire Act claim, was not substantial, and he did not rule on whether Kalshi’s contracts break New York gambling law.
He denied James’s request for attorneys’ fees because Kalshi had a reasonable basis for moving the case to federal court, and while no court has issued a new restraining order, James can now ask for one.
James sued on July 31, 2026. She says Kalshi runs unlicensed sports contracts and lets customers as young as 18 trade, even though New York’s minimum age is 21. She is seeking damages of three times the alleged gains, and one filing put the total she wants at a minimum of $36 billion.
Kalshi also points to a Commodity Futures Trading Commission emergency order from August 11, 2026, that ordered it to keep operating. If a state court tells Kalshi to stop while that federal order tells it to keep running, the two orders would conflict. No court has determined that question.
How Much of Robinhood Depends on Kalshi
Robinhood reports event contracts within Other Transaction Revenue, which reached $156 million[1] in the second quarter against total revenue of $1.308 billion. That is about 12% of quarterly revenue. Robinhood has not disclosed how much of it runs through Kalshi.
On October 27, 2026[2], the company’s CFO said Rothera, its exchange joint venture with Susquehanna, would be the primary venue. He said most flow would move to Rothera and Crypto.com/OG.com “by the end of the year into early next year,”[2] with Robinhood “getting off most of our competitors.”
Kalshi plans to offer stock and ETF trading within two months through FB Securities, a New York broker it bought in July. Robinhood fell 4% to $69.19 on November 17 after that report.
Robinhood still does not fully own or directly control Rothera, so the hedge is only partial. The stock is also down 43.41% year to date and 37.21% over the past month, with a beta of 2.528. A beta that high means the stock has historically moved far more than the market.
What Robinhood Investors Need to Track as the Kalshi Case Returns to State Court
Robinhood is already shifting its flow away from Kalshi, and the fee ruling found only that Kalshi had a reasonable basis to move the case to federal court.
The stock trades at a forward P/E of 25. Analysts still see recovery: the consensus target is $126.77, and 6 Strong Buy and 20 Buy ratings outweigh 4 Hold, 1 Sell and 1 Strong Sell.
One early test is whether Justice Crane grants a renewed restraining order before Robinhood completes moving its flow. After that, look for Kalshi’s response to a New Jersey Supreme Court petition, due Monday, December 7, and a state-court hearing on the Gaming Commission’s subpoenas on Monday, December 14. A nationwide order from Crane before year-end would put at risk the event-contract revenue Robinhood still routes through Kalshi.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.







