The Retirees Choosing Fort Wayne, Indiana, Over Florida Are Doing the Math on Taxes and Housing

Retiring in Fort Wayne, Indiana, versus retiring in Florida comes down to taxes, housing, and monthly costs, and here’s how much savings a couple needs to make either one work. The truth is that retirees move in both directions, as IRS migration data shows 7,213 tax returns moved from Florida to Indiana in 2022-2023, while 7,615 went the other way. This is what it takes to make Fort Wayne work, and where each place comes out ahead.

Indiana’s Tax Code Is Friendlier Than Its Reputation

Florida has the simplest pitch with no state income tax. Indiana’s rules are a lot closer than most people expect. The state deducts any federally taxable Social Security (Ind. Code § 6-3-1-3.5(a)(8)), so those checks aren’t taxed at the state level.

IRA withdrawals and pensions pay a flat 2.95% for 2026, dropping to 2.9% starting in 2027, and there’s room for further cuts if revenue targets are met. Counties also charge their own income tax, so check Allen County’s current rate. Sales tax is 7%.

Indiana’s largest advantage is property tax. Tax on a homestead is capped at 1% of gross assessed value. Beyond the standard deduction, there’s an additional 40% deduction for 2026 bills, rising to 46% in 2027. If you’re 65 or older, a separate credit increases by 2% each year, as long as joint income stays under a limit that starts at $70,000 and rises with Social Security cost-of-living adjustments. One catch for newcomers: the old over-65 deduction only covers assessment dates before January 1, 2025, so don’t plan around it.

Florida takes up to $25,000 off a homestead’s assessed value, plus another inflation-adjusted $25,000 on value above $50,000 for non-school taxes. Save Our Homes caps yearly assessment increases at the lower of 3% or inflation. The weak spot is insurance. Recent reporting blames insurance for making the American Dream cost more in Florida than the U.S. average, and Bloomberg has warned that the state’s new property-tax cut may bring an unwanted side effect.

A Monthly Budget for a Retired Couple

To keep the comparison fair, start with the average U.S. household’s spending of $81,905 and adjust it for each state’s price level. The BEA places Indiana at 93.329 and Florida at 103.414, where 100 is the national average.

Fort Wayne comes out ahead on everyday prices, plus property taxes are lower there. It has three rivers, a downtown riverfront park with a tree canopy trail, short drives, and major hospitals like Parkview. Florida comes out ahead on winters, direct flights, and the social life of its big retirement centers. Housing momentum has shifted, too. Fort Wayne’s price index rose 4.34% over the past year, while Cape Coral-Fort Myers slid 0.9%.

Turning the Gap Into a Portfolio Target

The Fort Wayne couple needs about $39,000 a year from savings after state taxes. Using a 4% withdrawal rate, a common planning benchmark, that’s roughly $977,000. The Florida couple would draw about $1.16 million. That’s about $179,000 before insurance quotes even come in.

If you retire before 65, use a lower withdrawal rate and the target goes up. Delaying Social Security reduces the gap in both places. On inflation, prices for older households rose 3.6% over the past year, the same as the 3.6% COLA coming in 2027.

Income Test Built Into Indiana’s Senior Tax Break

Indiana’s 2% cap on increases is tested against your federal adjusted gross income (AGI), the income figure on your federal return, from two years before the bill comes due. IRA withdrawals and the taxable part of your Social Security both count toward it. A big Roth conversion or a year of heavy IRA withdrawals can push you over the line. Then the cap is gone for that year’s bill.

Florida’s Save Our Homes cap has no income test. To keep the cap in Indiana, plan big withdrawals ahead of time. Pull some spending from Roth accounts or a taxable account, and spread conversions across several years (the quiet years between your last paycheck and your first RMD are usually the cheapest time to do this, which is the whole point of our free Roth conversion window guide).

What It Takes to Make Fort Wayne Work

Including state and local income taxes, the Fort Wayne couple would need roughly $992,000 at a 4% withdrawal rate. The Florida couple would need about $1.16 million, a difference of approximately $164,000.

Ultimately, keep AGI under Indiana’s income limit, file for the homestead deduction right away, and get Allen County’s local tax rate before you sign. Insurance plus property tax is a deciding cost line. Insurance plus property tax quotes for each home are the key figures to compare.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.