In order to thrive, cities must find ways to attract new businesses and new workers. The jury is still out on the best way to attract workers, and even on which workers cities should be attracting.

Some argue that in order for cities be able to build a successful, thriving economy, they need to attract a diverse array of workers, from technically proficient employees to those who are engaged in creative work. This wide range of workers includes people in the arts — music, theater, visual arts, etc. — as well as those engaged in technological development, such as engineers, programmers, and more.

These two groups — those involved with the arts and those working in technical product development — are of course very different, but they actually share many similarities. And according to some experts, it is the existence of both creative groups that makes a city thrive.

24/7 Wall St. conducted an analysis of Bureau of Labor Statistics employment data, using 2017 employment by occupation based on standard occupation codes. We ranked metropolitan areas that had the largest number of workers employed in jobs that could be considered creative per capita.

The list of cities includes many that the layperson would expect to see: tech strongholds like San Jose and cities with rich art scenes such as Portland, Oregon. The vast majority of these cities tend to represent a strong mix of both the arts and technological innovation.

The importance of cities developing a creative class was popularized by urban studies theorist Richard Florida in his book, “The Rise of the Creative Class.” Florida argued that a large base of highly-skilled, creative workers would thrive, and, importantly, choose to continue living in a city that has arts and other cultural attractions. An analysis of Yelp! data shows that most of the cities on this list contain a high share of cultural venues such as theaters, galleries, and museums. In general, the cities with the largest creative classes have the largest number of these cultural venues per capita.

Innovation in business is a key component of economic growth, and one way to measure the success of a large creative workforce is with patent grants. In general, the metropolitan areas on this list also have among the highest rates of patent recipiency over the past decade. San Jose, which ranks first on our list, has the most total patents awarded between 2000 and 2015. The vast majority of the metropolitan areas on this list are among the 30 largest patent recipients out of over 380 U.S. metropolitan areas.

Metro area	Creative jobs/ 1,000 pop.	Adults w/ Bachelor’s deg.	Rank	Patents granted, 2000-2015	Rank
United States	1.50	32.0%	.	..	..
New York, New York	1.83	39.6%	39	92577	2
Rochester, New York	1.84	34.1%	93	20239	19
Kansas City, Missouri	1.85	36.5%	66	7952	36
Baltimore, Maryland	1.87	39.5%	40	10574	28
Milwaukee, Wisconsin	1.95	35.8%	72	8988	33
Madison, Wisconsin	1.95	45.9%	18	5187	56
Palm Bay, Florida	1.95	30.0%	153	4922	58
Columbus, Ohio	1.96	35.9%	71	6165	49
Albany, New York	2.03	37.2%	58	10841	27
San Diego, California	2.04	38.8%	44	45465	7
Los Angeles, California	2.11	34.2%	91	74381	4
Cedar Rapids, Iowa	2.16	31.0%	138	2178	92
Minneapolis, Minnesota	2.22	41.7%	29	41696	9
Raleigh, North Carolina	2.22	46.2%	15	15950	21
Burlington, Vermont	2.26	43.0%	27	6263	48
Portland, Oregon	2.35	40.3%	34	25717	15
Salt Lake City, Utah	2.39	35.5%	77	6690	47
Denver, Colorado	2.43	43.9%	24	11436	24
Austin, Texas	2.57	44.8%	21	33753	12
Ann Arbor, Michigan	2.78	54.5%	2	7928	37
Durham, North Carolina	2.80	46.9%	14	6861	45
Detroit, Michigan	2.88	31.1%	133	37342	10
Boston, Massachusetts	3.02	47.6%	11	62653	5
Trenton, New Jersey	3.03	43.9%	24	5810	54
San Francisco, California	3.13	49.3%	9	89981	3
Seattle, Washington	3.38	41.9%	28	44406	8
California, Maryland	4.14	31.8%	127	#N/A	#N/A
Huntsville, Alabama	4.45	38.8%	44	2368	87
Boulder, Colorado	4.75	63.2%	1	9137	32
San Jose, California	6.51	50.8%	7	143473	1