Upstart Is Still Down 46% This Year: Did Today Just Mark the Bottom for UPST Stock?

One day after a quarter that coupled record profits with a weaker outlook, an AI-driven consumer lender is getting a sharp relief rally. Upstart Holdings (NASDAQ:UPST) shares trade at $23.63 this afternoon, up 11%. Even with that jump, Upstart stock is still down 46% year to date (YTD).

That raises a fair question: is this bounce a floor for Upstart or just a pause in a longer slide, since the answer may depend on credit conditions the company can’t control and Wall Street is split on how much they matter.

Record Profit Meets a Lower Upstart Outlook

Results for Q3 2026 arrived before the open on November 3, and Upstart’s fee engine looked strong. Revenue at Upstart rose to $370.52 million from $277.11 million in the year-ago quarter. Contribution profit at Upstart hit a record $218 million, up 48%, and its secured products reached a positive 17% contribution margin a quarter ahead of plan.

The bottom line was messier for Upstart. Upstart posted adjusted earnings per share (EPS) of $0.66. But its generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) EPS came in at $0.33 after negative fair value and other adjustments of $37.19 million tied to loans on its balance sheet.

For 2026, Upstart now expects total revenue of $1.35 billion and adjusted earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) of $260 million, down from its prior outlook of $1.4 billion and $294 million. CEO Paul Gu said borrower health and interest rates “became a sizable headwind in Q3 and have gotten worse to start Q4.”

Analysts and Management Make the Bull Case for Upstart

BTIG kept its Buy rating on Upstart stock on November 3 and trimmed its price target to $40 from $43. Piper Sandler (NYSE:PIPR) kept a Buy rating with a $35 target on Upstart. Needham held its Buy rating on Upstart with a $30 target.

Management’s argument rests on the core lending business. Upstart expects fee revenue and contribution profit to modestly beat its original 2026 plan, and it attributes the guidance cut mainly to weaker income from its balance sheet. Upstart also plans to open Upstart Bank in early 2027, pending regulatory approvals, and said funding the bank won’t require new equity capital.

Pagaya Technologies (NASDAQ:PGY), Upstart’s close peer, raised its 2026 GAAP net income guidance for the third time on October 29, to $162 million to $182 million. Gal Krubiner, Pagaya’s CEO, stated, “Pagaya is entering the fourth quarter with the largest pipeline in our history, up more than 50% year-over-year.” That suggests demand for AI-driven consumer credit is holding up, which supports the case for Upstart’s model.

Credit Risk Drives the Bear Case on Upstart

Morgan Stanley (NYSE:MS | MS Price Prediction) analyst James Faucette cut his Upstart stock price target to $24 from $35 and kept an Equal Weight rating on the shares. Faucette noted the quarter showed “solid execution on the factors within management’s control,” but added that credit conditions “continue to temper our confidence in the earnings outlook.”

A gauge built by Upstart itself shows the pressure building. The Upstart Macro Index (UMI) rose to 1.49 on October 5 from 1.39 at the end of 2025. Upstart’s updated guidance assumes the UMI stays at or below 1.55 through year-end.

At the end of June, Upstart’s maximum exposure to losses under loss-sharing funding deals was $1.29 billion, against stockholders’ equity of $797.5 million. That mismatch gives the bears a concrete risk to point to if defaults keep climbing.

How Pagaya and SoFi Frame Upstart’s Rebound

Pagaya stock is at $18.89, up 6% today. Year to date, Pagaya stock is down 10%, a much smaller decline than Upstart’s. Meanwhile, SoFi Technologies (NASDAQ:SOFI) stock is at $17.40, up 4% today. SoFi stock is still down 34% YTD, even after the company raised its 2026 adjusted net revenue guidance to $5.04 billion on October 27.

Differences in business models explain part of the gap. Pagaya builds its underwriting into the decision systems of banks and auto lenders, which then approve borrowers under their own brands, and with a bank charter, SoFi funds its loans with member deposits and also runs fee businesses and its Galileo technology platform. Upstart runs a marketplace that depends on third-party capital, and that’s why its planned bank matters.

What Could Decide Whether Upstart Has Found Its Floor

Upstart now faces the question of whether its reduced 2026 outlook holds up as new UMI readings come out each month. A steady index would support the bull view that fee growth and the new bank can carry the company, while a higher reading could compound the balance-sheet losses the bears point to. Credit commentary from Pagaya and SoFi offers a cross-check on Upstart, so watch for any change in their delinquency trends.

It’s still unclear whether this bounce marks the bottom for Upstart stock, and the evidence points both ways. A cautious investment approach could make sense until the path of the Upstart Macro Index is resolved.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.