Banking, finance, and taxes

Are Bank Stock Investors Ready for Lower Dividends and Lower Book Values?

Jon C. Ogg

Published: April 1, 2020 1:25 pm

Last Updated: September 19, 2022 12:51 pm

Everything was looking perfect for the banks at the start of 2020. Interest rates were expected to remain stable for the year, business was booming, equities and other assets were rising in value and regulators seemed to be easing up on the banks. Then came the COVID-19, and the raging bull market quickly turned into a roaring bear market and an instant recession. After a major sector sell-off, banks suddenly find themselves in a new quagmire in which investors may not be prepared for what is coming, despite having already seen large losses in their stock values.

There are three very specific and common trends that investors have been used to seeing for multiple years heading into 2020. That was strong stock buybacks, rising dividends and a steadily rising book value per share. The major U.S. banks already have shown that they will suspend buybacks during the economic malaise, but investors need to be concerned about potential announcements about dividend cuts, along with shrinking book values.

One issue that will be very difficult to judge, and with earnings acting as a benchmark for dividends, is what the earnings picture will look like in 2020 and 2021. Banks do not offer guidance, and the only known is that the earnings picture obviously will be “worse rather than better.” Moreover, earnings are likely to go drastically lower in the months ahead.

To factor in a worse environment, these are just some of the obvious items that will hurt bank earnings per share ahead: lower net interest margins, lower earnings on cash reserves, lower management fees on financial assets under management, a sharp decline in spending on credit cards, higher delinquencies and charge-offs on credit cards and loans, fewer car loans, lower mortgage activity, lower (safe) loan activity, lower investment banking activity, and so on. That’s even before getting into mortgage forgiveness and other deferred or missed payments that will start in April.

On top of major U.S. banks suspending share buybacks, the current period is only through the end of the second quarter. It seems unlikely that the Federal Reserve will want those banks to go out and aggressively start buying back stock after the end of June. Many politicians also are calling for major companies not to conduct stock buybacks, and the portion of the public that does not invest in stocks does not exactly view stock buybacks as an overall good.

Some of these risks may not be factored into the likes of Bank of America, Citigroup, Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan, Morgan Stanley, Wells Fargo and other key banks.

With an upcoming stress test coming from the Federal Reserve, the boom to bust in the course of a month has created an environment wherein the “severely adverse scenario” is no longer viewed as completely unrealistic. The banks just haven’t had to model for what could be 10% or 20% hits in gross domestic product. U.S. unemployment of 3.5% in prior months is also set to skyrocket due to the mandatory closure of businesses, followed by the overall weakness in the economy.

The banks in the United Kingdom are perhaps a benchmark for what else may be coming down the pipe in the weeks ahead. The major banks agreed to stop paying dividends and to halt stock buybacks for the rest of 2020 under a “request” by the Bank of England. This included the likes of HSBC Holdings PLC (NYSE: HSBC), Royal Bank of Scotland Group PLC (NYSE: RBS) and Barclays PLC (NYSE: BCS). The Bank of England already expects an increase in bad loans due to the coronavirus adding more pressure on top of the Brexit woes. These shares all traded lower in London trading, and this was the reaction in the New York-listed shares on Wednesday: −5% for RBS, −9% for Barclays and −9% for HSBC.

24/7 Wall St.
10 Dow Stocks Holding Up the Best in the 2020 Bear Market Carnage

Bank of America Corp. (NYSE: BAC) was last seen down about 6% at $20.00, and its dividend yield of 3.6% is not as high as some of the others because that dividend had been kept lower for longer by regulators. At the end of 2019, its book value was listed as $27.32, up from $26.96 in the prior quarter. Its tangible book value per share was $19.41, up from $19.26 in the prior quarter.

Citigroup Inc. (NYSE: C) ended 2019 with a tangible book value per share of $70.39 (up from $69.03 in the prior quarter) and a stated book value per share of $82.90 (up from $81.02 in the prior quarter). The current share price of $39.25 does not match up with those book values, and a current dividend yield of 4.8% on the common shares seems too high. Citi shares are down about 53% from their 52-week high.

Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (NYSE: GS) was down 4.7% at $147.35 on Wednesday. Its dividend yield was 3.4%. Goldman Sachs ended 2019 with a stated book value of $218.52 and a tangible book value per share of $205.15. Those compared with $218.82 and $205.50, respectively, in the prior quarter. This bank holding company’s stock price is still down about 40% from its highs.

JPMorgan Chase & Co. (NYSE: JPM) was down 5% at $85.35, with a 4.2% dividend yield. The bank’s tangible book value per share was $60.98 at the end of 2019 and $60.48 in the prior quarter. The top bank in the country has seen its stock drop 40% from its high.

Morgan Stanley (NYSE: MS) was recently down 7% at $31.50, with a current 4.4% dividend yield. Its book value was $45.82 per share and its tangible book value was $40.01 at the end of 2019. Morgan Stanley is down over 45% from its highs, and the acquisition of E*Trade is still pending.

Wells Fargo & Co. (NYSE: WFC) was down over 7% at $26.50, and its dividend would screen at 7.7% at this time. Wells Fargo is still under stronger scrutiny than the other major banks due to its account opening scandals and other operational flaws in recent years. The stock is down almost 52% from its 52-week high, but that is down closer to 60% from the highs seen before the account scandals hit.

24/7 Wall St.
6 Oil and Gas ‘Survivors’ That Are Incredibly Solid Contrarian Buys Now

The good news so far is that the only item that has been cut in the United States is the stock buybacks, and so far that is only temporary. The bad news is that earnings could get bad enough in the recession that dividends and book values could all come under pressure if the current economic situation gets much worse and stays that way.

Banks do not offer earnings guidance when they report results. It is also very likely that the two emergency rate cuts and rapid deterioration in March may not see their full implications hit until April and May. That means the earnings may look or feel artificially better than they would be had the market and economic carnage started in January instead of February, then ramping into the abyss in March.

Bank earnings will be coming out in the next two to three weeks. The Federal Reserve’s Comprehensive Capital Analysis and Review (CCAR, or stress tests) are not due until June, and by then the markets will have witnessed just how bad the monthly economic numbers look.