Worst US States for Winter Driving

Special Report

Published: February 8, 2024 8:32 am

Whether they realize it or not, getting behind the wheel is the most dangerous thing many Americans do every day. According to the U.S. Department of Transportation, there were over 39,500 fatal crashes nationwide in 2021, resulting in nearly 43,000 deaths — the most in over a decade and a half.

Many risk factors associated with driving are outside the control of even the safest motorists. These not only include not only distracted, drowsy, or reckless drivers, but also weather conditions — particularly in the winter months. In much of the country, winter weather conditions can close lanes, limit visibility, reduce vehicle maneuverability, and greatly increase the likelihood of an accident.

Data from the DOT shows that nearly a quarter of all weather-related crashes in the U.S. occur on icy, slushy, and snowy roads. These conditions contribute to more than 1,300 roadway deaths and over 116,800 injuries every year in the United States. In some parts of the country, fatal winter weather crashes are far more common than in others. (Here is a look at the most dangerous cars on the road.)

Using data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 24/7 Wall St. identified the worst states for winter driving. States are ranked on the total number of fatal crashes between 2017 and 2021 in winter weather conditions — including snow, sleet, and freezing rain — for every 100,000 licensed drivers. The total number of licensed drivers by state, as reported by the DOT, is for the 2020 calendar year.

Among the 30 states on this list, the number of fatal winter-weather crashes between 2017 and 2021 ranges from fewer than 1 for every 100,000 drivers to over 12 per 100,000. While every state on this list is subject to hazardous winter driving conditions, fatality rates are also subject to a number of other related factors, including road maintenance.

Bordering two great lakes, which can produce devastating lake-effect winter storms, New York state is home to some of the snowiest counties in the continental United States. However, New York was also the only state to apply over 900,000 tons of salt to the roads in the winter of 2020 through 2021 to reduce the likelihood of ice forming. Despite its susceptibility to hazardous winter driving conditions, New York was one of only four states to report fewer than 1 fatal winter-weather crash per 100,000 drivers in the last five years.

Population density also appears to play a role. Rural areas tend to have much higher fatal crash rates than urban areas, and many of the highest ranking states on this list are largely rural. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, only 20% of Americans live in rural areas — but in eight of the 10 worst states for winter driving, over a third of the population reside in rural areas. (Here is a look at the most challenging American cities to drive in.)

These are the worst states for winter driving.

30. Massachusetts

Source: Adam Glanzman / Getty Images News via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 0.65 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 32 (1.5% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2019, 8 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 6 per year

29. Connecticut

Source: DenisTangneyJr / iStock via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 0.72 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 18 (0.8% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 7 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 4 per year

28. New York

Source: Spencer Platt / Getty Images News via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 0.75 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 92 (4.3% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 25 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 18 per year

27. Washington

Source: Furchin / Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 0.84 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 49 (2.3% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2017, 16 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 10 per year

26. New Mexico

Source: KatieIrene / Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 1.15 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 17 (0.8% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2019, 7 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 3 per year

25. Oregon

Source: oregondot / Flickr

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 1.22 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 36 (1.7% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2017, 13 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 7 per year

24. Kentucky

Source: volgariver / iStock via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 1.24 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 36 (1.7% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 10 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 7 per year

23. Colorado

Source: tvirbickis / Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 1.35 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 58 (2.7% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2021, 14 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 12 per year

22. Illinois

Source: UWMadison / iStock via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 1.37 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 113 (5.3% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 32 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 23 per year

21. Pennsylvania

Source: catnap72 / E+ via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 1.55 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 138 (6.5% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 30 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 28 per year

20. Missouri

Source: dvids / Flickr

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 1.67 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 71 (3.3% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 28 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 14 per year

19. Utah

Source: kenlund / Flickr

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 1.67 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 36 (1.7% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2017, 8 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 7 per year

18. Ohio

Source: styxclick / Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 1.88 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 152 (7.1% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 36 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 30 per year

17. Indiana

Source: porkkala / iStock via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 1.94 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 88 (4.1% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 23 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 18 per year

16. Kansas

Source: gacooksey / E+ via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 2.25 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 45 (2.1% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2019, 15 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 9 per year

15. Wisconsin

Source: William Reagan / iStock via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 2.41 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 104 (4.9% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 30 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 21 per year

14. Idaho

Source: knowlesgallery / iStock via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 2.41 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 31 (1.5% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2019, 10 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 6 per year

13. Minnesota

Source: LawrenceSawyer / iStock via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 2.44 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 100 (4.7% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 25 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 20 per year

12. New Hampshire

Source: Daniel Hanscom / iStock via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 2.55 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 27 (1.3% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2017, 10 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 5 per year

11. Iowa

Source: DarcyMaulsby / Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 2.73 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 62 (2.9% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2019, 20 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 12 per year

10. Maine

Source: DenisTangneyJr / iStock via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 3.05 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 32 (1.5% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 10 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 6 per year

9. Michigan

Source: TracieMichelle / iStock via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 3.15 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 221 (10.4% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 56 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 44 per year

8. West Virginia

Source: dvids / Flickr

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 3.27 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 36 (1.7% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2019, 11 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 7 per year

7. Nebraska

Source: leonaruth / iStock via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 3.61 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 52 (2.4% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 18 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 10 per year

6. South Dakota

Source: Jacob Boomsma / Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 4.10 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 27 (1.3% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2020, 8 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 5 per year

5. North Dakota

Source: dlerick / Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 5.38 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 29 (1.4% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 11 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 6 per year

4. Vermont

Source: Alex Boudreaux / iStock via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 5.42 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 25 (1.2% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2018, 7 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 5 per year

3. Montana

Source: powdr_dayz / iStock via Getty Images

Winter weather fatal crash rate, 2017-2021: 5.44 per 100,000 licensed drivers
Total fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 45 (2.1% of U.S. total)
Worst year for winter driving, 2017-2021: 2021, 13 fatal crashes
Avg. number of fatal crashes in winter conditions, 2017-2021: 9 per year

2. Alaska